Recommendations for Local Columbus and Environs Restaurants
Compiled by Dr. John V. Richardson, OCLC VDS 1996/97 and updated September 2009
614 area
Type Name Address Telephone Speciality Cost Recommender Evaluation
American 94th Aero Squadron CMH Airport; Sawyer Road 237-8887 Prime Rib $$ Craig Morgan Good view; great WW1 décor; cheese beer soup
American Cameron's 161, Linworth $$$$ Parents Great lemon cheese cake
American Cap City 1299 Olentangy River Rd. 291-3663 $$ OCLC Scholars Good meatloaf
American G&R Grill Waldo, 40 miles Fried Bologna Sandwich $ Paul  
American Gibby's Riverview 6125 Scioto River Road 717-9102 $$ OCLC Scholars Good ambiance; double check your charge card
American Hoggy's Morse and 62 Ribs Craig
American Hyde Park 569 North High Street 224-2204 Prime Rib $$$$ Craig Petit Filet Mignon
American Max & Erma's 411 Metro Place N 889-8111   Jim Vickroy Like TGIFriday's
American Morgan House 5300 Glick Road, Dublin 889-5703 Wonderful cordon bleu chicken salad sandwich $ HSR Love the fact that house originally belonged to a g-g-grandfather
American Nancy's 3133 North High Street 265-9012 Breakfast and Lunch $ JR Greasy spoon
American NorthStar 951 North High Street 298-9999 Meatloaf, it's not just comfort food $ JR Recommended by Justin, the waiter at Rigsby's
American Otie's Restaurant 5344 Center St 876-1548 Bologna $ Jeff and Bradley Excellent; no smoking section is too small
American Red Door Tavern 1736 W 5th Avenue 488-5433 Hillybilly Hamburger $ OCLC Scholars Dark and Divey; good onion rings
American Scottie's McBean 4675 North High Street Breakfast $ Drove By Coffee house; Wi-Fi
Austrian Mozart's Bakery 2885 North High Street 268-3687 Bakery $ Lisa Fresh Orange juice and excellent pastry; not much in the way of cooked breakfast
BBQ City BBQ 6199 N. Cleveland Ave. 823-8890 North Carolina BBQ $ Columbus Monthly Pulled Pork Sandwich with two sides
BBQ Pig Iron 5295 N High  885-4744 $ JR;  Better in St. Louis or Kansas City
Chinese Moy's Chinese Restaurant High at Arps Parking Hunan Shrimp over Rice $ Tim McNiven Popular with OSU Chinese students
Cuban Galaxy Cafe 33 Beechridge Drive 846-7776 $ Eric Miller  
Desserts Just Pies 5525 North High Street 888-0021 Excellent Home Made Ones $ JR Try the Cherry Pie!
French La Chatelaine 627 North High Street $ French bread is better in France; good OJ and onion soup
French Refectory 1092 Bethel Road 451-9774 $$$$ Columbus Monthly Good selection of wines
German Schmidt's German Village Bahama Mama $$ JR Good German pilsner beer and cream desserts.
Greek Acropolis Gyros 5328 North Hill 888-7728 "The Ultimate Gyros" $ JR Yes, but not the home made baklava
Greek Niki's Moved to Cleveland Avenue 885-2895
Indian Tandoori Chicken 1677 W Lane Ave 486-6288 JR
Italian Belleria 128 Graceland Blvd. 433-7500 Antipasto Salad $ JR the salad is big enough for four!
Italian Bono's To Go Relocating Fall 2009 906-8646 Pizza to go by Bill Yerkes; two or three tables outside $ JR Recommended by Justin, the waiter at Rigsby's
Italian Bravo Italian Kitchen 3000 Hayden Road 791-1245 Personal Pizza; caesar salad, signature $$ Thom Hickey Chain, but nice decor; good service
Italian Café Bella High and Hudson $ Paul
Italian Moretti's 5849 Sawmill Road 717-0400 Veal Parmigiana $ Parents Good service; excellent veal
Italian Pizza House Sinclair Road 885-3121 Best Pizza in Columbus (except for Bono's in Short North) $ JR since 1966 Rated one of Col's Best; it probably is
Italian Rigsby's North High Street Blue Plate Lunch Specials for $10!; Veuve Cliquot $$$ JR Excellent for lunch or New Years Eve Celebrations
Italian Smith's 3737 N. High 263-1855 $ JR Good antipasto salad
Japanese Ginza 6329 Perimeter Loop Rd 798-9588 $$ Bradley Good tempura; Otani is probably better
Japanese Otani 5900 Roche Drive 431-333 $$ OCLC Scholars Delicate Tempura
Mexican Café Fiesta $ Eric Miller
Mexican Chili Verde 4852 Sawmill 442-6630 Jim Vickroy
Mexican Don Pablo 3740 W Dublin-Granville 761-7624 $ Eric Miller
Mexican La Hacienda Real 4865 Sinclair Road 781-0624 Hacienda Espeical $ JR Authentic for the Mid-West
Mexican Tapatio 491 N Park  221-1085 Paul
Middle East Café Istanbul 3983 Worth in Easton Town Center 473-9144 Authentic Turkish Cuisine under ExCef Fatih Gunal $$ Ali Hassan Doner Kebab is really good
Middle East Aladdin's 6804 Perimeter Loop 588-0330 Middle Eastern $ Jean Godby Good, not great hummous, reasonably priced
Seafood Columbus Fish Market 40 Huntington Avenue 410-3474 fresh daily $$ Craig Morgan Colossal Shrimp and Crab in Season (May)
Spanish Barelona 263 East Whitter Street 443-3699 $$ Craig Morgan
Cost: $=under $15; $$=$15-25; $$$=$25-35; $$$$=over $35